MMonster Anthology
Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story backdrop

Season 2 · Episode 5 · September 19, 2024

The Hurt Man

One unbroken monologue: Erik's account, in the season's most discussed hour.

Updated

Season
Season 2 — Menendez
Episode
Episode 5 of 9
Premiere
September 19, 2024
Platform
Netflix
Rating
TV-MA
Part of
Monster anthology

Watch

Monster Season 2, Episode 5 — The Hurt Man (video)YouTube

Cooper Koch on playing Erik — official Still Watching Netflix feature.

The episode

Structurally the simplest and most discussed hour of the season: Erik, in a prison visiting room, telling Leslie his account in what plays as a single unbroken monologue.

The content is the abuse — the grooming, the rape, the learned belief that this was how his father loved him, the mother's rituals of checking him for disease. Whatever a jury later makes of the killings, the episode argues that this testimony — believed or disbelieved — is the hinge everything else swings on.

Show vs. the record

Erik's description of grooming and rape by his father, and of his mother's conduct, was the core of the defense and the reason this hour exists. The allegations were contested in court. The retrial jury did not accept them as the explanation for the killings.

The single unbroken take is a filming decision. It is not how the testimony was given.

New to the season? Start with the Season 2 guide for the full picture, or the watch order to see how the anthology fits together.

Keep watching

Browse every guide on the seasons index or jump to the Season 4 hub for the newest chapter of the anthology.