MMonster Anthology
Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story backdrop

Season 2 · Episode 9 · September 19, 2024

Hang Men

The retrial's verdict, separate prisons, and one last sailing trip in flashback.

Updated

Season
Season 2 — Menendez
Episode
Episode 9 of 9
Premiere
September 19, 2024
Platform
Netflix
Rating
TV-MA
Part of
Monster anthology

Watch

Monster Season 2, Episode 9 — Hang Men (video)YouTube

The ensemble, from the brothers to the courtroom — official cast feature.

The episode

The retrial, without cameras and with the abuse defense pared to the bone, ends the way the tabloids wanted: guilty of first-degree murder, life without parole, and separate prisons that end the brothers' daily contact for decades.

The season closes in flashback — a family sailing trip, José pushing Kitty back toward her career, the brothers below deck discussing the plan — freezing the story at the last moment before anyone was a killer or a victim, and leaving the argument to the viewer.

Show vs. the record

In 1996 both brothers were convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life without parole. They were held in separate prisons for years. That is the ending of the retrial.

Later resentencing and parole hearings sit outside this episode. The closing sailboat, and the plan discussed below deck, are the series leaving the argument with the viewer.

New to the season? Start with the Season 2 guide for the full picture, or the watch order to see how the anthology fits together.

Keep watching

Browse every guide on the seasons index or jump to the Season 4 hub for the newest chapter of the anthology.