MMonster Anthology
Dahmer — Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story backdrop

Season 1 · Episode 9 · September 21, 2022

The Bogeyman

Families sue the city while fan mail turns the case into merchandise.

Updated

Season
Season 1 — Dahmer
Episode
Episode 9 of 10
Premiere
September 21, 2022
Platform
Netflix
Rating
TV-MA
Part of
Monster anthology

Watch

Monster Season 1, Episode 9 — The Bogeyman (video)YouTube

Official making-of feature: the cast and Ryan Murphy on building the series.

The episode

Grief turns procedural: lawyer Joe Zilber files a $14 million suit against the City of Milwaukee on the families' behalf, and Shirley Hughes is pushed to sue Lionel over book profits — the season watching victims fight over the scraps of an atrocity.

Meanwhile the culture machine spins up: fan mail, autographed merchandise, dealers pricing Dahmer's belongings. Zilber's counter is the episode's one clean note — he buys everything at double the asking price and destroys it, then hands the families their shares of the loss.

Show vs. the record

Families did take the city to civil court, and there was a real trade in Dahmer's belongings after the trial. The episode names a lawyer, a dollar figure, and a choice to buy those items in order to destroy them.

Treat the motive and the amount as the series compressing that aftermath. The suit and the memorabilia trade are the part that belongs to the record.

New to the season? Start with the Season 1 guide for the full picture, or the watch order to see how the anthology fits together.

Keep watching

Browse every guide on the seasons index or jump to the Season 4 hub for the newest chapter of the anthology.